Guantánamo’s ghosts and the shame of Diego Garcia

22.10.07

One of the more sordid and long-running stories in Anglo-American colonial history –- that of Diego Garcia, the chief island of the Chagos Archipelago in the Indian Ocean –- reared its ugly head again on Friday when the UK’s all-party foreign affairs committee announced plans to investigate long-standing allegations that the CIA has, since 2002, held and interrogated al-Qaeda suspects at a secret prison on the island.

Diego Garcia

The shameful tale of Diego Garcia began in 1961, when it was marked out by the US military as a crucial geopolitical base. Ignoring the fact that 2,000 people already lived there, and that the island –- a British colony since the fall of Napoleon –- had been settled in the late 18th century by French coconut planters, who shipped in African- and Indian-born labourers from Mauritius, establishing what John Pilger called “a gentle Creole nation with thriving villages, a school, a hospital, a church, a prison, a railway, docks, a copra plantation,” the Labour government of Harold Wilson conspired with the administrations of Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon to “sweep” and “sanitize” the islands (the words come from American documents that were later declassified).

Although many islanders traced their ancestry back five generations, a British Foreign Office official wrote in 1966 that the government’s aim was “to convert all the existing residents … into short-term, temporary residents,” so that they could be exiled to Mauritius. Having removed the “Tarzans or Men Fridays,” as another British memo described the inhabitants, the British effectively ceded control of the islands to the Americans, who established a base on Diego Garcia, which, over the years, has become known as “Camp Justice,” complete with “over 2,000 troops, anchorage for 30 warships, a nuclear dump, a satellite spy station, shopping malls, bars and a golf course.” So thoroughly were the islands cleared –- and so stealthy the procedure –- that in the 1970s the British Ministry of Defence had the effrontery to insist, “There is nothing in our files about a population and an evacuation.”

Diego Garcia's former residents in happier times

Diego Garcia’s former residents in happier times.

Suffering in exile, the Chagos islanders have struggled in vain to secure the right to return to their ancestral home, winning a stunning victory in the High Court in 2000, which ruled their expulsion illegal, but then suffering a setback in 2003, when, with typically high-handed authoritarianism, Tony Blair invoked an ancient and archaic “royal prerogative” to strike down their claims once more. Although the appeal court reversed this decision in May 2006, ruling that the islanders’ right to return was “one of the most fundamental liberties known to human beings,” it remains to be seen how this belated judicial recognition of their rights can be squared with the Americans’ insistence that their military-industrial archipelago must remain unsullied by outsiders.

In their resistance to the islanders’ claims, Blair and the Foreign Office were clearly protecting the interests of their American allies, for whom the geopolitical importance of Diego Garcia as a strategic base had recently been augmented by its use –- and the use of some of the ships moored there –- as fabulously remote offshore prisons in which to hold and interrogate “high-value” al-Qaeda suspects.

The suspicion, which the foreign affairs committee has pledged to investigate, is that on Diego Garcia the Americans found a far more compliant partner in torture –- the British government –- than they found in most other locations chosen for secret CIA prisons. According to various reports over the years, the Americans’ other partners in the offshore torture game –- Thailand, Poland and Rumania, for example –- were only prepared to be paid off for a while before they got cold feet and sent the CIA packing.

Whether the committee will probe deeply or not remains to be seen. The British-based legal charity Reprieve, which has called for such an investigation for some time, has already told the committee in a submission that it believes that the British government is “potentially systematically complicit in the most serious crimes against humanity of disappearance, torture and prolonged incommunicado detention.” Clive Stafford Smith, Reprieve’s legal director, told the Guardian that he is “absolutely and categorically certain” that prisoners have been held on the island.

When questioned by diligent MPs like Andrew Tyrie, the Conservative MP for Chichester, who is a staunch opponent of the CIA’s use of “extraordinary rendition,” the British government has persistently maintained that it believes “assurances” given by the US government that no terror suspects have been held on the island, but there are several compelling reasons for concluding, instead, that the government is actually being economical with the truth.

Studies of planes used by the CIA for its rendition program –- which can be found on Stephen Grey’s excellent Ghost Plane site –- have established that on September 11, 2002, the day that 9/11 plotter Ramzi bin al-Shibh was seized after a firefight in Karachi, one of the CIA’s planes flew from Washington to Diego Garcia, via Athens. Bin al-Shibh did not resurface again until September 2006, when he was moved to Guantánamo, and he has not spoken about his experiences. Unlike his supposed mentor Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, he refused to take part in his tribunal at Guantánamo earlier this year, but this is not the only piece of the torture jigsaw that has been reconstructed by diligent researchers.

In June 2006, Dick Marty, a Swiss senator who produced a detailed report on “extraordinary rendition” for the Council of Europe, also concluded that Diego Garcia had been used as a secret prison. Having spoken to senior CIA officers during his research, he told the European Parliament, “We have received concurring confirmations that United States agencies have used Diego Garcia, which is the international legal responsibility of the UK, in the ‘processing’ of high-value detainees.”

Anecdotally, Marty’s findings have been confirmed by other sources. Manfred Novak, the UN’s Special Rapporteur on Torture, declared that he heard from “reliable sources” that the US has “held prisoners on ships in the Indian Ocean,” and detainees in Guantánamo have also told their lawyers that they were held on US ships –- in addition to those held on the USS Bataan and the USS Peleliu, which are discussed in my book The Guantánamo Files. One detainee told a researcher from Reprieve, “One of my fellow prisoners in Guantánamo was at sea on an American ship with about 50 others before coming to Guantánamo. He told me that there were about 50 other people on the ship; they were all closed off in the bottom. The people detained on the ship were beaten even more severely than in Guantánamo.”

The most incriminating evidence of all, however, has come not from opponents of Guantánamo, or, indirectly, from those subjected to some of the regime’s most horrendous abuses, but from an upstanding insider. Barry McCaffrey, a retired four-star US general, who is now professor of international security studies at the West Point military academy (whose recent report on Guantánamo was ridiculed here), has twice let slip that Diego Garcia has, as the administration’s opponents have struggled to maintain, been used to hold terror suspects. In May 2004, he blithely declared, “We’re probably holding around 3,000 people, you know, Bagram air field, Diego Garcia, Guantánamo, 16 camps throughout Iraq,” and in December 2006 he slipped the leash again, saying, “They’re behind bars … we’ve got them on Diego Garcia, in Bagram air field, in Guantánamo.”

Do we need any further proof?

Andy Worthington is the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison (published by Pluto Press, distributed by Macmillan in the US, and available from Amazon — click on the following for the US and the UK). To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to my RSS feed.

As published on CounterPunch and Indymedia.

See here for further developments in the story of the secret prison on Diego Garcia.

10 Responses

  1. Andy Worthington says...

    After this article was published, John Francis Lee wrote to me from Thailand to say, “Thanks Andy. This is very important information to be brought to the fore. To have our noses rubbed in. Thanks, again.”

    And German Leyens let me know that it has been translated into Spanish at: http://www.rebelion.org/noticia.php?id=58039

    Thanks to both of you.

  2. Andy Worthington says...

    Another two comments:

    Bob Fearn wrote, “Thanks, Andy, for the Diego Garcia piece. You might be interested in a short chapter that deals with that issue on page 273 in this book that can be downloaded for free. Go to: http://www.amoralamerica.info.”

    And Mary Catherine Barton wrote, “Thank you for this wonderful article published in Counterpunch. I am so sorry to learn about my government deliberately secretly brutalizing foreigners. In fact, I am sick to death of so much evil done by our powerful military against the caged unarmed. Please keep the spotlight on. You are doing so much good.

    “In my studies of the history of Ireland, in particular, I am well aware of the willingness of the English to torture without giving a damn. Now I know about us, US, maybe Mukasey won’t be affirmed for AG. I’ve let Congress know what I think.”

  3. Andy Worthington says...

    This just in:

    Dear Mr Worthington

    I recently read your piece in CounterPunch, dated 20th October 2007, entitled “The Shame of Diego Garcia”. You may be interested to hear what a small band of concerned people are doing to try to highlight this matter further. If you have a few minutes to spare please go to our website http://www.peoplesnavy.com for details. You will see pledges from politicians, professors, authors, doctors and people from all walks of life listed.

    Pete Bouquet (original captain of “Rainbow Warrior” and long time member of Greenpeace) and his son Sam are sailing to the Chagos islands in January with the express purpose of highlighting the issues and history of the islanders. They will be taking photographs and movies and making general observations of the state of the islands and surrounding waters (particularly illegal fishing activities) and the houses and associated infrastructure. They will also take note of any obvious neglect by the British Authorities of Chagossian property, and vandalism or damage which has occurred during the absence of the rightful owners.

    After learning of the plight of the Chagossians and the intended voyage 4 weeks ago, my partner and I have built a website for this expedition and would be very interested in your feedback. The website will keep everyone updated on their journey with a constant feed from both boats.

    We showed Jon Pilger’s “Stealing a Nation” to 150 boat owners here in Marmaris and the response was overwhelming in its emotion and shock. They have rallied round and donated many useful “yachtie” bits of equipment and knowledge. We all feel that our community, which is worldwide and made up of every culture has a role to play in seeking justice for the Chagossians and people like them. We are inviting fellow sailors to sign up their boats to “The Peoples Virtual Navy” and to pledge their support for the project.

    ”The main and overriding reason for using boats for peaceful protest is that we can get to places that others cannot. We can shine the spotlight on hidden and secret abuses. We can bear witness to injustices and get the message to the outside world. A boat arouses emotion and sympathy in the eyes of observers who have no preconceived ideas or prejudices. They identify with the struggles of those on board, who have the courage and ability to pit themselves against the elements.” Pete Bouquet, June 2004.

    Sam was recently interviewed for the Mauritian Times and you can see the article here: http://www.mauritiustimes.com/071207chagos.htm

    Kind regards

    Liz Cleere

  4. Cia&Friends » Blog Archiv says...

    [...] Guantanamo ghosts and the shame of Diego Garcia (Andy Worthington) [...]

  5. Scandal of Diego Garcia Rendition Flights says...

    [...] Garcia and the surrounding islands — known collectively as the Chagos Islands — were shamefully cleared of their existing population in the late 1960s, to make way for a US airbase on Diego Garcia [...]

  6. Alex Jones' Infowars: There's a war on for your mind! says...

    [...] exiled to face destitution and death by misery in Mauritius — Diego Garcia has long been a source of shame to opponents of modern colonial [...]

  7. Secret Prison on Diego Garcia Confirmed: Six “High-Value” Guantánamo Prisoners Held, Plus “Ghost Prisoner” Mustafa Setmariam Nasar | freedetainees.org says...

    [...] and exiled to face destitution and death by misery in Mauritius — Diego Garcia has long been a source of shame to opponents of modern colonial activity. Until now, however, the only admission that any [...]

  8. Secret “War on Terror” Prison on Diego Garcia Confirmed | Infinite Unknown says...

    [...] exiled to face destitution and death by misery in Mauritius — Diego Garcia has long been a source of shame to opponents of modern colonial [...]

  9. Secret CIA prison on Diego Garcia confirmed « From Behind Bars says...

    [...] and exiled to face destitution and death by misery in Mauritius — Diego Garcia has long been a source of shame to opponents of modern colonial activity. Until now, however, the only admission that any [...]

  10. exotraxx division: discover US Disneyland - a reader dedicated to my US American friends says...

    [...] Andy Worthington, Guantánamo’s ghosts and the shame of Diego Garcia [...]

Leave a Reply

Back to the top

Back to home page

Andy Worthington

Investigative journalist, author, filmmaker, photographer and Guantanamo expert
Email Andy Worthington

The Guantánamo Files book cover

The Guantánamo Files

The Battle of the Beanfield book cover

The Battle of the Beanfield

Stonehenge: Celebration & Subversion book cover

Stonehenge: Celebration & Subversion

Outside The Law DVD cover

Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo

RSS

Posts & Comments

World Wide Web Consortium

XHTML & CSS

WordPress

Powered by WordPress

Designed by Josh King-Farlow

Please support Andy Worthington, independent journalist:

Archives

In Touch

Follow me on Facebook

Become a fan on Facebook

Subscribe to me on YouTubeSubscribe to me on YouTube

Andy's Flickr photos

Campaigns

Categories

Tag Cloud

Afghans Al-Qaeda Andy Worthington Bagram British prisoners CIA torture prisons Clive Stafford Smith Close Guantanamo David Cameron Guantanamo Habeas corpus Hunger strikes Lewisham London Military Commission NHS NHS privatisation Photos President Obama Reprieve Save Lewisham A&E Shaker Aamer Taliban Torture UK austerity UK protest US Congress US courts WikiLeaks Yemenis