The Cruelty and Stupidity of the Government’s Welfare Reforms


Journalists like to portray Iain Duncan Smith, the work and pensions secretary, as a caring, decent man, but while this may be true in his personal life, politically he is a ruthless ideologue, whose white paper on welfare reform, unveiled yesterday, reveals that he is, to be blunt, monstrously cruel and stupid. In the Daily Telegraph on Saturday, Mary Riddell provided a cautionary warning about how this would-be reformer’s mind works, which harks back uncomfortably to the Social Darwinism of the Victorian age. Duncan Smith, she wrote, “believes that dysfunctional lives are the root cause of poverty, while the centre Left thinks, correctly, that the reverse is true.”

Although everyone in Parliament seems to agree with Duncan Smith’s assessment that the tangled welfare system needs an overhaul, and that the notion of a universal credit is a good idea, the details in his white paper, unveiled in Parliament yesterday — which followed a shocking claim on BBC4’s “Today” programme that not taking a job was “a sin” — were greeted with horror by anti-poverty campaigners, who, quite rightly, accused Duncan Smith of creating a “climate of fear” and of exposing the most vulnerable families and children to the “risk of destitution.” In addition, Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury — a man whose job involves a more professional assessment of what constitutes “a sin” than that of a politician — also weighed in, warning that the plans were unfair and could plunge the unemployed into “a downward spiral of uncertainty, even despair”.

Under Duncan Smtih’s proposals, the long-term unemployed will be required to do unpaid community work, and unemployed people will be obliged to take whatever jobs are offered to them. If they refuse, they will lose their benefits for three months. If they refuse twice, they will lose benefits for six months, and if they refuse for a third time, they will be deprived of their benefits for three years. Elsewhere, a mainstay of authoritarian governments — attacking single mothers — resurfaced, as Duncan Smith promised that out-of-work parents of young children — those with children between the age of one and five — “will be penalised if they fail to keep in touch with their local jobcentre.”

The main problem with Duncan Smith’s proposals — which appears to me to be blindingly obvious, but is not even perceived by an alarmingly large number of my flint-hearted fellow citizens — is that it paints a picture of millions of workshy scroungers shirking work opportunities, which is fundamentally at odds with the actual situation in the job market.

Given that the government’s own figures show that there are currently 2.45 million unemployed people, and just 459,000 available jobs (and with the government having vowed to add another 1.3 million to the jobless total in the imminent future), beating up on the unemployed with such a variety of sticks is nothing short of heartless.

With one job available for every five people unemployed, only someone who has put ideology before common sense (as Duncan Smith admitted at the weekend, when he told the Telegraph that this particular period in time — during a recession — was “a dreadful period to try and do any of this”) would want to penalize every single person who doesn’t take up a job that is offered them, would want to harangue single parents with babies and toddlers (almost always mothers) in their own homes, would delight in humiliating the long-term unemployed — and undermining the minimum wage — by making them work for their benefit (presumably in orange jackets that will make them look like convicted criminals doing community service), and would delight in continuing the onslaught on the mentally and physically disabled that was begun by the Labour goverment.

In a malignant campaign to eradicate invalidity benefit, which began in 2008, Labour replaced it with employment support allowance, and then recruited malleable doctors to give disabled claimants tests and pronounce that almost anyone with a pulse was capable of work (see here for an appraisal by Edward Lawrence, a disabled man supported by the State). However, the new government has now taken this one step further, announcing that employment support allowance will only last for one year, after which those claiming it will be downgraded to jobseekers’ allowance, leaving campaigners concluding, with some justification, that a shockingly large number of people with long-term health problems will be consigned to a minimum of state support, even though their chances of ever finding a job are, to put it midly, remote. — or, as Polly Toynbee put it yesterday, “Large numbers who have been on incapacity benefit for years, who even in good times were pretty unemployable, will now lose a large slab of their income on the spurious grounds that they could, in theory, be fit for something or other.”

As the Guardian explained last month, according to estimates from the Department for Work and Pensions, about 290,000 people “are likely to be deemed too incapacitated to work, and will not see their benefits time-limited,” but 865,000 people on incapacity benefit will be “placed in the ‘work-related activity group,’ who will see their benefits cut after one year.” The Guardian also pointed out that “Those with assets, savings or partners who work will no longer receive benefits. They will not be able to claim JSA even if they are out of work, so would therefore have to rely on partners’ income or savings — if they have any — or sell off their assets.”

For those, like the government, who persist in ignroing evidence that the tests are unfair, Anjuli Veall, social policy and campaigns manager at Parkinson’s UK, said, “In spite of the government’s assurance that any cuts would protect the most vulnerable in society, we are concerned that the latest policy shift regarding ESA will unnecessarily target people with long-term conditions, such as Parkinson’s,” which, to my mind, indicates the extent to which the seriously ill are being regarded as fit for work.

A final problem with Duncan Smith’s reforms is that, although they involve an attempt to help those on low pay out of a benefit trap, where they end up poorer by working, they fail to address a far better solution: raising the minimum wage, as Mehdi Hasan noted in the Guardian on Tuesday, when he explained that, according to a recent report from the Institute for Public Policy Research, there are 1.7 million children in working households identified as living in poverty, and 3.4 million adults. Hasan also pointed out that the TUC has recommended to the low pay commission that it raises the minimum wage by 21p (3.5%) to £6.14 from October 2011 (which, it says, would save the government about £125m in tax credits and in-work benefits), but as he also noted, Tories have always despised the minimum wage, introduced in 1999, and “In opposition, Tory sources suggested the minimum wage would be allowed to ‘wither on the vine.'”

In contrast, as John Harris noted in the Guardian today, “on 3 November, a Treasury minister named Lord Sassoon served notice that the coalition’s work on City bonuses was done.” Lord Harris stated, “The government has taken action to tackle unacceptable bonuses in the banking sector,” meaning, as previously reported, that an annual £2.5 bn levy on the City — almost all of which will be returned due to a convenient reduction in Corporation Tax — is the sum of the government’s demands on the City fat cats who got us into this mess in the first place. As Harris also noted, “Six days later, Barclays announced that its latest bonus pot would total £1.6bn.” In the context of his article, framed around the proposed demolition of university funding, he pointed out that this is “about a third of what the government currently spends each year on university teaching,” although it should also be noted that it is about two-thirds of what the government plans to save through its remorseless assault on the disabled.

In conclusion, then, my message to Iain Duncan Smith is simple: ask the City for more money before you start hitting the poor, think long and hard about your duty of care to people with disabilities, create two million new jobs and raise the minimum wage, and then I might be prepared to listen. Until then, however, I will resist your self-righteous cruelty with every fibre of my being, and will encourage everyone I meet — whose heart has not yet frozen over — to do the same.

Andy Worthington is the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison (published by Pluto Press, distributed by Macmillan in the US, and available from Amazon — click on the following for the US and the UK) and of two other books: Stonehenge: Celebration and Subversion and The Battle of the Beanfield. To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to my RSS feed (and I can also be found on Facebook and Twitter). Also see my definitive Guantánamo prisoner list, updated in July 2010, details about the new documentary film, “Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo” (co-directed by Polly Nash and Andy Worthington, currently on tour in the UK, and available on DVD here), and my definitive Guantánamo habeas list, and, if you appreciate my work, feel free to make a donation.

21 Responses

  1. criticalbill says...

    Great pieces (this & the one on the student protest). They go hand in hand with this one from todays LRB. You can only feel that people will be screaming blue fucking murder once they get their heads around whats being done.

  2. Andy Worthington says...

    Too right, Bill. Great to hear from you — and thanks for the LRB link.

  3. Andy Worthington says...

    On Facebook, Imran Chaudhry wrote:

    trying to reshape an already broken system is like trying to fix broken glass to look perfect again. Too transparent pun intended, unbelievable the audacity of these people

  4. Andy Worthington says...

    Karen Martin wrote:

    Wow, Andy, I feel like I was reading about upcoming cuts in the U.S. towards the poor and unemployed. Do the English protest more vocally than Americans when it comes to cuts to the poor and unemployed? I don’t think middle class America and maybe middle class Brits understand how easily they too can join the ranks of the poor and unemployed. On War Crimes, as you all know, my country seems not to have the will nor the interest in prosecuting war criminals, is there any chance of prosecuting in the Hague or something?

  5. Andy Worthington says...

    Thanks for the comments, everyone.
    Karen, your comment about the middle classes is spot-on, and I think the middle classes here are realizing what’s going on. Cameron claims he’s middle class, but that’s the type of middle class worth £3.4m, and not the sort with two working parents trying to keep their heads above water. He’s completely out of touch, as are the other 18 millionaires in the cabinet, and it’s why the growing rebellion — for the first time in 20 years — will include everyone except the rich, the very rich and the deluded.
    As for war crimes, the Hague is out of the question because the US refused to sign up to the ICC, but there are cases proceeding in Europe (in Spain and Poland, at least) if Obama persists in refusing to put America’s house in order.

  6. Mithra Harding says...

    Hi Andy

    The list is endless and I put a lot of the blame on labour government and Tony Blair as most MPs are professional politicians whichever political party they belong to. I said most as I know there will be some who will not change opinions with whichever the direction the wind is blowing. the new policies are not just going to affect the unemployed but those of us working too. If my rent is increased to 80% of market value, i will not be able to afford to live in my own home, look after 3 children. My eldest is a wheelchair user and is in first year of uni. I have 2 more at home. i did not choose to be divorced and live on my own and support and look after 4 of us, but we will be more hard hit. The MPs live in a world where they do not understand how real people live their lives. Tony Blair owns 9 properties now, and He will not care about how he left the state of affairs as long as he and his family are ok.

  7. Andy Worthington says...

    Thanks for the comments, Mithra. Good to hear from you.

  8. The Cruelty and Stupidity of the Government’s Welfare Reforms « Dandelion Salad says...

    […] Andy Worthington Featured Writer Dandelion Salad 12 November, 2010 14 November, […]

  9. Andy Worthington says...

    Karen Martin wrote:

    ‎1. on economies of U.K. and U.S., or rather its victims, the poor and disappearing middle classes……..all I see is a return to something out of the feudal era in Europe…albeit a modern day version….I hope I’m wrong.
    2. on U.S. and it’s war criminals…I will cheer and celebrate heartily if ever I see a serious prosecution take place…here or abroad. I’m sick to death of U.S. being a rogue state.
    The only reason I continue to have hope is for the fact there are so many good people, sadly our voices are muffled by the media and the corporatocracy in general.

  10. Andy Worthington says...

    Ruth Gilburt wrote:

    I agree and sometimes I feel totally defeated by the enormity of the struggle…but there is no alternative but to keep challenging…x

  11. Uncreative People on the Backs of the Young « thatcher's grandsons says...

    […] "The Cruelty and Stupidity of the Government’s Welfare Reforms" and related posts ( 0.000000 0.000000 Categories: butt off and butt out, have you got the butter it takes – get rid of House of Lords Back Benchers and Armchair Sleepers, Ian Duncan Smith persistant in working people down to the ground, it's about great butter not about tory money, it's not about great britain it's about Great Butter, NHS Public Services – not to be seen only to be doing, tell the government to butter off LikeBe the first to like this post. Comments (0) Trackbacks (0) Leave a comment Trackback […]

  12. Black Triangle Campaign says...

    This government must GO!

  13. Battle for Britain: Resisting the Privatization of the NHS and the Loss of 100,000 Jobs | says...

    […] — hard-pressed middle class and working class people, students, schoolchildren, the working poor, the unemployed and the disabled; everyone, in fact, except the rich and the […]


    […] le difficoltà dei ceti medi e degli operai, degli studenti, delle scuole, dei lavoratori poveri, dei disoccupati e dei disabili; in effetti di tutti tranne i ricchi e i super ricchi. Guidati dal disgustoso desiderio ideologico […]

  15. The Year of Revolution: The War on Tyranny Replaces the War on Terror « Dandelion Salad says...

    […] its attacks on welfare, on university funding, on the NHS, and on almost every aspect of the British state that has not […]

  16. The Year of Revolution: The “War on Tyranny” Replaces the “War on Terror” « Eurasia Review says...

    […] its attacks on welfare, on university funding, on the NHS, and on almost every aspect of the British state that has not […]

  17. On the Anti-Cuts Protest in London | Amauta says...

    […] in my articles, Critics Attack UK Government’s Cruel and Ill-Conceived Assault on Welfare, The Cruelty and Stupidity of the Government’s Welfare Reforms and On Housing Benefit Cuts, British Public Reveals Shocking Lack of Empathy and […]

  18. Brutal UK Benefit Cuts For Disabled Leading To Suicides - OpEd says...

    […] Brutal UK Benefit Cuts For Disabled Leading To Suicides – OpEd Written by: Andy Worthington June 7, 2011 var addthis_product = 'wpp-257'; var addthis_config = {"data_track_clickback":true};When it comes to callousness, the supposedly caring veneer of David Cameron’s Tory party disintegrated almost as soon as the expedient governing coalition with the hapless Liberal Democrats was formed, when our new leaders announced, with evident relish, their intention of haranguing those without work at a time when there was only one job available for every five unemployed people. […]

  19. Andy Worthington’s Blog: ‘Brutal Benefit Cuts for the Disabled Are Leading to Suicides in the UK’ | Black Triangle Campaign says...

    […] When it comes to callousness, the supposedly caring veneer of David Cameron’s Tory party disintegrated almost as soon as the expedient governing coalition with the hapless Liberal Democrats was formed, when our new leaders announced, with evident relish, their intention of haranguing those without work at a time when there was only one job available for every five unemployed people. […]

  20. Darren says...

    Lets face it, this corrupt government is on it’s way out you can upset some people some of the time, but the coalition is upsetting every damned thing in this country. Welfare reform – nothing but undesirables are the disabled people to this government, they are being hounded, humiliated, and given crumbs. It worked for Hitler, it will work for his political twin David Cameron’ too.

  21. Andy Worthington says...

    I hope so, Darren. Good to hear from you, and I agree with you about the Nazi analogies. Some people think that’s going too far, but this is the first government in my lifetime that actively regards those at the “bottom” as undeserving of any kind of support.

Leave a Reply

Back to the top

Back to home page

Andy Worthington

Investigative journalist, author, campaigner, commentator and public speaker. Recognized as an authority on Guantánamo and the “war on terror.” Co-founder, Close Guantánamo, co-director, We Stand With Shaker. Also, singer and songwriter (The Four Fathers) and photographer.
Email Andy Worthington

CD: Love and War

Love and War by The Four Fathers

The Guantánamo Files book cover

The Guantánamo Files

The Battle of the Beanfield book cover

The Battle of the Beanfield

Stonehenge: Celebration & Subversion book cover

Stonehenge: Celebration & Subversion

Outside The Law DVD cover

Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo


Posts & Comments

World Wide Web Consortium



Powered by WordPress

Designed by Josh King-Farlow

Please support Andy Worthington, independent journalist:


In Touch

Follow me on Facebook

Become a fan on Facebook

Subscribe to me on YouTubeSubscribe to me on YouTube

Andy's Flickr photos



Tag Cloud

Abu Zubaydah Afghans in Guantanamo Al-Qaeda Andy Worthington British prisoners Center for Constitutional Rights CIA torture prisons Clive Stafford Smith Close Guantanamo David Cameron Guantanamo Hunger strikes London Military Commission NHS NHS privatisation Periodic Review Boards Photos President Obama Reprieve Shaker Aamer Torture UK austerity UK protest US Congress US courts Video We Stand With Shaker WikiLeaks Yemenis in Guantanamo