Judge Upholds Ruling Ordering Independent Medical Review for Tortured Guantánamo Prisoner Mohammed Al-Qahtani


A composite image of Guantánamo prisoner and torture victim Mohammed al-Qahtani and District Judge Ellen Huvelle.

Please support my work as a reader-funded journalist! I’m currently trying to raise $2500 (£2000) to support my writing and campaigning on Guantánamo and related issues over the next three months of the Trump administration. If you can help, please click on the button below to donate via PayPal.


Back in March, as I explained in an article at the time, District Judge Rosemary Collyer made history when she ordered the US government to allow independent medical and psychiatric experts from outside the US to assess a prisoner at Guantánamo.

The prisoner in question is Saudi national Mohammed al-Qahtani, who had pre-existing serious mental health issues that the US authorities failed to disclose when, at Guantánamo, they came to regard him as the intended 20th hijacker for the 9/11 attacks, and subjected him to a torture program involving months of sleep deprivation and sexual humiliation.

Judge Collyer’s ruling involved her, as Carol Rosenberg explained for the New York Times, stating that “she was granting a request” by al-Qahtani’s lawyers “to compel the United States to apply an Army regulation designed to protect prisoners of war and to create ‘a mixed medical commission’ made up of a medical officer from the US Army and two doctors from a neutral country chosen by the International Committee of the Red Cross and approved by the United States and Saudi Arabia.”

As Rosenberg also stated, “In ordering the evaluation, Judge Collyer relied on a report from Dr. Emily A. Keram, an American psychiatrist who treats US veterans and who examined Mr. Qahtani at Guantánamo and some of his medical records in Saudi Arabia.” Her report noted that al-Qahtani “spent four or five days in the psychiatric unit of a hospital in Mecca, Saudi Arabia, after an ‘acute psychotic break’ and a suicide attempt in May 2000,” and she also noted that he “suffered a head injury in a car accident when he was a child and was subsequently diagnosed with schizophrenia.” As Rosenberg put it, “One symptom included hallucinations; he spoke to nonexistent people before he left Saudi Arabia and after his arrival at Guantánamo.”

As Rosenberg also explained, “Central to Judge Collyer’s order was the contention by Mr. Qahtani’s lawyers that Guantánamo was not equipped to handle his psychiatric illnesses, and that he was entitled to repatriation to culturally appropriate mental health care under the prisoner-of-war provisions in the Army regulations.”

Judge Collyer has since retired, but, taking over the case, District Judge Ellen Huvelle last Wednesday rejected an effort by the government to “put on hold” Judge Collyer’s order, as Ben Fox explained for the Associated Press, describing al-Qahtani as a prisoner who “was so badly mistreated in American custody that he cannot be put on trial.”

The Justice Department had said that it intended to appeal the March decision, but Judge Huvelle “noted in her ruling that, due to his health, the risk of delay to the prisoner ‘far outweighs’ any potential harm to the government from dispatching a team of doctors to evaluate him.”

She also noted that government lawyers had “failed to demonstrate either a likelihood of success on the merits or that the balance of harms weighs in their favor.”

Ben Fox proceeded to run through al-Qahtani’s history in US custody, explaining, as should always be noted, that his is the only example of torture by US forces that has been acknowledged by a senior US official — Susan Crawford, the convening authority for the military commission trial system at Guantánamo. As Fox put it, al-Qahtani was “subjected to treatment that was so brutal that the Pentagon legal official in charge of the war crimes tribunals determined that it amounted to torture and he could not be prosecuted.”

Fox also explained that the US government “has never said what it plans to do with him” — as, indeed, is the case with all of the “forever prisoners” still at the prison, 26 of the 40 prisoners still held, who are not facing prosecution, and are, instead, held indefinitely without charge or trial, in defiance of all internationally recognized norms regarding imprisonment.

As Ben Fox further explained, Judge Huvelle factored his history of mental health issues into her decision, stating, in her ruling, “Mr. al-Qahtani’s mental health issues were evident to US government officials when he was first detained at Guantánamo Bay and have been exacerbated by the torture he initially suffered at the hands of the US government and the over 18 years he has spent in detention.”

Writing about the “mixed medical commission,” Fox also explained that the Saudi government has already agreed to al-Qahtani’s return.

In contrast, the government continues to argue that, as Fox described it, “al-Qahtani can get any medical treatment he needs at Guantánamo,” and that “creating a Mixed Medical Commission, which has never before been provided for a prisoner at the detention center, would set a precedent that would inspire others to seek one as well.”

This may well be the case, but what it shows, surely, is that al-Qahtani is not the only prisoner deprived of an appropriate assessment of his physical and mental state.

Ramzi Kassem, a law professor at the City University of New York, and one of al-Qahtani’s attorneys, said that “he thinks the government is worried about what an independent medical panel would conclude about his client,” as Fox described it. As Kassem put it, “They’re concerned the mixed medical commission will come back and say he meets the criteria for medical repatriation.”

Judge Huvelle noted that “it would likely take some time to put together a medical panel and dispatch it” to the prison, especially as the authorities have had to “put restrictions on visitors due to the COVID-19 pandemic that have brought legal proceedings against other detainees to a standstill,” but, crucially, she has continued to support Judge Collyer’s insistence that al-Qahtani needs the kind of medical assessment that his captors have, shamefully, failed to provide in 18 years.

* * * * *

Andy Worthington is a freelance investigative journalist, activist, author, photographer, film-maker and singer-songwriter (the lead singer and main songwriter for the London-based band The Four Fathers, whose music is available via Bandcamp). He is the co-founder of the Close Guantánamo campaign (and see the latest photo campaign here) and the successful We Stand With Shaker campaign of 2014-15, and the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison and of two other books: Stonehenge: Celebration and Subversion and The Battle of the Beanfield. He is also the co-director (with Polly Nash) of the documentary film, “Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo” (available on DVD here, or here for the US, or you can watch it online here, via the production company Spectacle, for £2.55), and for his photo project ‘The State of London’ he publishes a photo a day from eight years of bike rides around the 120 postcodes of the capital.

In 2017, Andy became very involved in housing issues. He is the narrator of the documentary film, ‘Concrete Soldiers UK’, about the destruction of council estates, and the inspiring resistance of residents, he wrote a song ‘Grenfell’, in the aftermath of the entirely preventable fire in June 2017 that killed over 70 people, and he also set up ‘No Social Cleansing in Lewisham’ as a focal point for resistance to estate destruction and the loss of community space in his home borough in south east London. For two months, from August to October 2018, he was part of the occupation of the Old Tidemill Wildlife Garden in Deptford, to prevent its destruction — and that of 16 structurally sound council flats next door — by Lewisham Council and Peabody. Although the garden was violently evicted by bailiffs on October 29, 2018, and the trees were cut down on February 27, 2019, the resistance continues.

To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to Andy’s RSS feed — and he can also be found on Facebook (and here), Twitter, Flickr and YouTube. Also see the six-part definitive Guantánamo prisoner list, The Complete Guantánamo Files, the definitive Guantánamo habeas list, the full military commissions list, and the chronological list of all Andy’s articles.

Please also consider joining the Close Guantánamo campaign, and, if you appreciate Andy’s work, feel free to make a donation.

4 Responses

  1. Andy Worthington says...

    When I posted this on Facebook, I wrote:

    Good news as a US judge, District Judge Ellen Huvelle, upholds a ruling from March by another judge who has now retired, Judge Rosemary Collyer, requiring the US government to allow a US doctor and two foreign doctors to visit Guantanamo to assess the mental health of Mohammed al-Qahtani, and to allow him to be sent home to Saudi Arabia if they assess that the authorities at Guantanamo are not equipped to handle his mental health issues.

    Al-Qahtani is a Saudi national who was subjected to a vile torture program at Guantanamo when he was suspected of being the intended 20th hijacker for the 9/11 attacks, even though the US authorities knew that he had serious pre-existing psychiatric problems.

    After 18 years, he deserves a truly independent review of his mental health, which, if it goes ahead, will be the first time that foreign medical experts will have been allowed to visit the prison.

  2. Anna says...

    Bless Judge Huvelle and may this umptiest groundhog day experience meet a speedy & constructive conclusion. And yes, by all means, most if not all of the other 39 no doubt also should receive the visit of such a team. Much as I dislike Biden, he unfortunately is now the only hope for them.

  3. Andy Worthington says...

    Yes, and there’s already pressure on Biden behind the scenes, Anna, because there will be some progress on Guantanamo if he is elected, even if it is just the release of insignificant prisoners, halving the prison’s population, for example. Closing it completely, I have to conclude, may, sadly, be beyond the ability of any electable leader; not that I will give up calling for it, obviously, but the plight of those tortured in CIA “black sites” demonstrates, above all, how, once you have tortured someone, you remove the ability to give them a fair trial.

  4. Andy Worthington says...

    For a Spanish translation on the World Can’t Wait’s Spanish website, see ‘El juez ratifica una sentencia ordenando una revisión médica independiente para el prisionero de Guantánamo torturado Mohammed Al-Qahtani’: http://worldcantwait-la.com/worthington-juez-ratifica-sentencia-ordenando-revision-medica-independiente.htm

Leave a Reply



Back to the top

Back to home page

Andy Worthington

Investigative journalist, author, campaigner, commentator and public speaker. Recognized as an authority on Guantánamo and the “war on terror.” Co-founder, Close Guantánamo and We Stand With Shaker. Also, photo-journalist (The State of London), and singer and songwriter (The Four Fathers).
Email Andy Worthington

CD: Love and War

The Four Fathers on Bandcamp

The Guantánamo Files book cover

The Guantánamo Files

The Battle of the Beanfield book cover

The Battle of the Beanfield

Stonehenge: Celebration & Subversion book cover

Stonehenge: Celebration & Subversion

Outside The Law DVD cover

Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo


Posts & Comments

World Wide Web Consortium



Powered by WordPress

Designed by Josh King-Farlow

Please support Andy Worthington, independent journalist:


In Touch

Follow me on Facebook

Become a fan on Facebook

Subscribe to me on YouTubeSubscribe to me on YouTube

The State of London

The State of London. 16 photos of London

Andy's Flickr photos



Tag Cloud

Afghans in Guantanamo Al-Qaeda Andy Worthington British prisoners Center for Constitutional Rights CIA torture prisons Close Guantanamo Donald Trump Four Fathers Guantanamo Housing crisis Hunger strikes London Military Commission NHS NHS privatisation Periodic Review Boards Photos President Obama Reprieve Shaker Aamer The Four Fathers Torture UK austerity UK protest US courts Video We Stand With Shaker WikiLeaks Yemenis in Guantanamo