It has long been a regret of mine that I don’t have enough time to write about the domestic prison system in the US, because of the distressing scale of incarceration in the US (the highest per capita rate in the world, by far) and also because of the violence and brutality, and the use of prolonged isolation, that mirrors much of what has been taking place at Guantánamo and elsewhere in the “War on Terror” for the last nine years.
Fortunately, two weeks ago NPR ran a major feature on a disturbing aspect of the isolation regime in domestic US prisons, focusing on the little-known Communications Management Units (CMUs), located in Terre Haute, Indiana, and Marion, Illinois, where the inmates are mostly Muslims, who are subjected to surveillance 24 hours a day, have their mail monitored, and are prevented from having any physical contact whatsoever with their families during prison visits –behavior that is more reminiscent of Guantánamo than of the rest of the domestic prison system.
Although Muslims make up the majority of the prisoners in the CMUs, there appears to be little internal logic regarding who is held and why, as those held range from foreign nationals involved in major acts of international terrorism to American citizens involved in fundraising for organzations acting as alleged fronts for terrorism and others caught in US government sting operations, which rather tends to enforce the notion that a large part of the CMUs’ rationale involves racial and religious profiling.
The prisoners also include — or have included — individuals involved in various forms of political activism, including environmental activism, and others for whom the rationale for keeping them under 24-hour surveillance appears to be that they “have spoken out at other prison units and advocated for their rights” and/or “have taken leadership positions in religious communities in those other prisons,” and/or because “officials worry that they could recruit other inmates for terrorism or direct people in the outside world to commit crimes.”
If you didn’t come across the NPR feature, I’ve cross-posted below the main article, “Guantánamo North”: Inside Secretive U.S. Prisons, but I also recommend a shorter follow-up article, Leaving “Guantanamo North”, and two other parts of the NPR feature that are not reproduced here: TIMELINE: The History Of ‘Guantanamo North’ and, in particular, DATA & GRAPHICS: Population Inside The CMUs, which contains the names and details of the 86 prisoners (and ex-prisoners) identified in the NPR report.
And if this subject interests you, then please read my follow-up article, Guantánamo in America (Part Two): The Nation Reveals More About the Secretive Prison Units for Muslims and Other Perceived Threats.
Reports about what life is like inside the military prison for terrorism suspects at Guantánamo Bay are not uncommon. But very little is reported about two secretive units for convicted terrorists and other inmates who get 24-hour surveillance, right here in the U.S.
For the first time, an NPR investigation has identified 86 of the more than 100 men who have lived in the special units that some people are calling “Guantánamo North.” The Communications Management Units in Terre Haute, Ind., and Marion, Ill., are mostly filled with Muslims. About two-thirds of the inmates identified by NPR are U.S. citizens.
Civil rights groups have filed lawsuits that accuse the U.S. facilities of some of the same due process complaints raised by people at the island prison.
Who Belongs In The Prison Units?
Avon Twitty, 56, knows a lot about these Communications Management Units, or CMUs. He spent three years in one. These days, he lives in a house with chipped white paint, next to a highway in Washington, D.C.
This is the first time he has talked about his experience.
Twitty spent 27 years in prison for shooting a man dead after a neighborhood argument in the 1980s. Years before that, he converted to Islam. He has never been convicted of a terrorist offense.
But prison officials sent him to one of the special units in Terre Haute to finish out the remaining few years of his sentence. Twitty says he never found out why. He has a piece of paper saying he allegedly took part in “radicalizing” people, but the transfer document doesn’t explain who, or why. Twitty reads from one of the many letters he wrote to prison leaders, asking for answers.
“So my question was, what government agency labeled me a terrorist?” Twitty asks. “… What terrorist offense did I commit against the American government or any American citizen? What evidence demonstrated my guilt? Why was I not afforded my constitutional right to a due process hearing?”
Inside The Special Units
Prison officials opened the first CMU with no public notice four years ago, something inmates say they had no right to do under the federal law known as the Administrative Procedures Act.
The special unit in Terre Haute contains 50 cells housing some of the people the U.S. describes as the country’s biggest security threats, including John Walker Lindh.
He was picked up on the battlefield in Afghanistan, after fighting on the side of the Taliban. Prison officials have never released the names of inmates in Terre Haute or in a companion unit in Marion. But an NPR investigation found out who some of them are.
The units’ population has included men convicted in well-known post-Sept. 11 cases, as well as defendants from the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, the 1999 “millennium” plot to bomb the Los Angeles airport, and hijacking cases in 1976, 1985 and 1996.
Also under surveillance in the CMUs are men who have threatened officials from behind bars, ordered murders using contraband cell phones, or engaged in other communications that officials want to monitor.
The population also includes several black Muslims who have been disciplined for alleged radicalization and recruitment while incarcerated for other crimes.
As word got out that the special units were disproportionately Muslim, civil rights lawyers say, the Bureau of Prisons started moving in non-Muslims.
The group included tax resisters, a member of the Japanese Red Army and inmates from Colombia and Mexico. Inmates say the guards there called them “balancers.”
The Bureau of Prisons says a total of 71 men now live in the units.
Alexis Agathocleous, a lawyer at the Center for Constitutional Rights, has a hunch about how the population came to be.
“We were concerned about what appears to be racial profiling and also a pattern of designations to the CMUs of people who have spoken out at other prison units and advocated for their rights and have taken leadership positions in religious communities in those other prisons,” he says.
They are segregated from other prisoners because officials worry that they could recruit other inmates for terrorism or direct people in the outside world to commit crimes.
American University law professor Stephen Vladeck reviewed NPR’s findings. He says he has some questions about the secrecy surrounding the units and whether the prison is sending the right people there.
“I think the real question is, what are the constraints and how are we sure that the right people are being placed in these units and not the wrong ones?” Vladeck says.
“Mixing prisoners from different backgrounds who actually don’t necessarily live up to those criteria I think is troubling,” Vladeck adds, because it means some inmates might not belong there, and others who do belong may not be getting the attention they deserve.
NPR found two reports, marked “law enforcement sensitive,” from 2009. In them, intelligence analysts for the Bureau of Prisons describe religious tension among different Muslim groups in the special units, including at least one violent episode involving a man described as an enforcer.
In those units, people convicted of international terrorism mingle with more conventional criminals. So Omar Mohammed Ali Rezaq, who hijacked an EgyptAir flight with other members of a Palestinian terrorist group in 1985, lives in the CMU along with Muslims who were convicted in U.S. government sting operations but who didn’t have the resources to carry out a plot on their own.
Eavesdropping And Restrictions
Guards and cameras watch the CMU inmates’ every move. Every word they speak is picked up by a counterterrorism team that eavesdrops from West Virginia. Prison officials budgeted more than $14 million for the snooping operation last year, according to appropriations documents and congressional testimony.
Restrictions on visiting time and phone calls in the special units are tougher than in most maximum security prisons. Inmates who lived in the CMUs and their spouses talked to NPR about them for the first time.
Hedaya Jayyousi’s husband, Kifah, served in the U.S. Navy. He also taught engineering. Then he was convicted of supporting groups in Bosnia and Chechnya that the U.S. government says are tied to terrorism. Kifah Jayyousi has lived in both CMUs.
Mrs. Jayyousi now looks after their five children. Unlike most other prison inmates, the people in the CMUs are not allowed so-called contact visits, where they can touch their families. They get fewer hours of visiting time and fewer phone privileges, too.
“What happens is we really get very stressful because the way the visit [is] set,” Hedaya Jayyousi says, “we need to hold the phone in our hands, very thick glasses. You can’t hear him. [The girls] can’t touch him.”
A History Of Lawsuits
For the past year, Twitty and other inmates have been suing the Federal Bureau of Prisons. They say the special units were set up outside the law and raise serious due process issues. Unlike prisoners who are convicted of serious crimes and sent to a federal supermax facility, CMU inmates have no way to review the evidence that sent them there or to challenge that evidence to get out.
Twitty says he actually spent months longer in prison than he had to because of his designation to the special CMU unit. The halfway house in Washington wouldn’t accept him for several months.
A federal judge in Washington, D.C., is considering whether to let the prisoners go forward with the lawsuit.
Agathocleous, from the Center for Constitutional Rights, is representing the CMU inmates in their ongoing civil rights case (Aref, et al. v. Holder, et al.). He says he’s noticed something about his clients:
“There is a tenfold over-representation of Muslim prisoners at the CMUs,” he says. “So 6 percent of the national prison population is Muslim, and somewhere in the neighborhood of between 66 and 72 percent of prisoners at the CMUs are Muslim.”
Harley Lappin, who leads the Bureau of Prisons, described the special units to Congress in 2009.
“You’ve got a second tier where we don’t have to have them as restricted, but we want to control their communications,” Lappin told members of the U.S. House of Representatives. “They are housed in Communications Management Units where we can target, again, communication, both written and verbal, and oversee visits more adequately than in our general population facilities.”
The unit at Terre Haute includes open cells, an outdoor basketball court and a dining room with checkerboards painted on some of the tables, according to Ken Falk, a lawyer at the American Civil Liberties Union in Indiana. He is one of the few people to see inside the unit at Terre Haute and is representing several inmates in a lawsuit (Arnaout et al. v. Warden) that alleges that the Communications Management Unit violates their religious rights.
He says Muslim inmates are allowed to do all kinds of things together, except pray. That, he says, is breaking a law known as the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The law requires the federal government to follow the least burdensome approach when it comes to peoples’ religious faith and practice.
“The problem from our perspective in the CMU is that the prisoners are out anyway and they’re allowed to engage in all sorts of activity, and they’re not allowed to engage in group prayer,” Falk says. “In fact, prisoners have been punished when two prisoners have gone back to their cells together to pray.”
Ed Ross, a spokesman for the Bureau of Prisons, didn’t want to comment on the court cases. He says the special units help make sure inmates are monitored at all times. The units are designed for people convicted of terrorism, prisoners who have dealt drugs or tried to recruit or radicalize others behind bars; and prisoners who have abused their communications privileges by harassing victims, judges and prosecutors, Ross says.
Terrorism experts say all those restrictions in the special units might minimize radicalization inside U.S. prisons. The Justice Department inspector general and some members of Congress say that has been a big problem in the past.
Andy Worthington is the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison (published by Pluto Press, distributed by Macmillan in the US, and available from Amazon — click on the following for the US and the UK) and of two other books: Stonehenge: Celebration and Subversion and The Battle of the Beanfield. To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to my RSS feed (and I can also be found on Facebook, Twitter, Digg and YouTube). Also see my definitive Guantánamo prisoner list, updated in July 2010, details about the new documentary film, “Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo” (co-directed by Polly Nash and Andy Worthington, on tour in the UK throughout 2011, and available on DVD here — or here for the US), my definitive Guantánamo habeas list and the chronological list of all my articles, and, if you appreciate my work, feel free to make a donation.
On Facebook, Lynne Jackson wrote:
My innocent friend, Yassin Aref, is in Little Gitmo in Marion, Ill. The restrictions on communication with his family are severe. Yassin, with the help of CCR, is suing over his being put there. As an American, I am horrified that we have these horrid prisons.
Reagan Sullivan wrote:
Really, Terre Haute, the home of Eugene Debs?! Shameful!
Lynne Jackson wrote:
In Albany, NY we are having a conference on the issue, see http://www.projectsalam.org/events/03-30-11.html
Lynne Jackson wrote:
This is what Yassin said about the prison: http://www.albanyweblog.com/2007/10-Oct/10-14-07.html
Amy Mueller wrote:
Prolonged segregation is increasingly becoming a problem in US prisons and it is in place under the guise of punishment and safety. One of the inmates I work with was taken off of death row to be put into segregation for six months and having all of her goods taken from her. There is no reason for this other than individual people upset that her death sentence was over-turned, though the ‘official’ reason is to monitor her as she transitions from death row to general population. (How does segregation help a transition when one was segregated in death row to begin with?) BUT, should a foreign government hold a US citizen in solitary for more than a few days, they are torturing our citizen. Doesn’t matter that we do it to our own citizens. Doesn’t matter that we do it to the citizens of other countries. The systematic violations of basic human rights of prisoners within the US is maddening – the fact so few people care makes me feel insane.
Finding Eden wrote:
Its not about justice or punishment….its Control of the masters..
Chris Cook wrote:
The (Not So) Strange Case of Dr. Dhafir: http://pacificfreepress.com/news/1/2271-gorilla-radio-with-chris-cook-katherine-hughes-stephen-marshall-j9-feb-11-2008.html
Lynne Jackson wrote:
Dr. Dhafir is still in the CMU in Terre Haute, IN. He was sentenced to 22 years for something other physicians would be required to offer a refund. Here is an excellent piece written about his case: http://www.truth-out.org/humanitarian-pays-with-life-feeding-children-iraq68317
Ghaliyaa Haq wrote:
I have a story for you but you can’t write it…. :-/
George Kenneth Berger wrote:
I’m sharing this. I hope you are doing well.
Thanks, everyone. My hope — with this and the second part I’ve just published, featuring an article by Alia Malek from the Nation — was to introduce some of my regular readers on Guantanamo and related issues to the world of the CMUs, and the US prison system in general, as it’s easy for them to be overlooked, and they are, of course, the poisonous bedrock on which Guantanamo was constructed.
I had intended to publish these in fairly swift succession over the weekend, but some of you, reading between the lines, may have figured out that something has rather derailed me from my usual output. That something is the suspension of my normal life, and my admission to Lewisham Hospital on Friday, and then to St. Thomas’s Hospital on Sunday, to deal with a horribly painful problem with my right foot, in which several toes have been starved of blood because of arterial damage elsewhere in my body. I’ll be writing more about this soon.
Obama promised to end this horrible prison in one year once in office…what happened?
I’m so disappointed.
Alternet today has good article on this same subject.
Thanks, Carlyle. That’s the article from the Nation that I cross-posted in Part Two.
Normally, people of whatever religious persuasion are isolated in the Bureau of Prisons because they are dangerous, Members of the Wahabi sect of Islam are particularly odious. To say that these people are isolated simply because they are Muslim is another lie by the propagators of eternal jihad. Example, years ago, the Muslims at a (federal) maximum security institution threatened the (contract) Imam because he was Sunni!….
ISLAM is eternal jihad, nothing more.
I don’t censor comments unless they’re personally offensive, but that’s a ridiculous statement. What about Christianity? Isn’t that a hugely warlike religion? It seems to me that “eternal jihad” would be an accurate description of how some Christian countries behave.
Investigative journalist, author, campaigner, commentator and public speaker. Recognized as an authority on Guantánamo and the “war on terror.” Co-founder, Close Guantánamo, co-director, We Stand With Shaker. Also, singer and songwriter (The Four Fathers) and photographer.
Email Andy Worthington
Please support Andy Worthington, independent journalist: