David Frakt is our foremost authority on the Military Commissions. He is not an ideologue, but a dispassionate analyst of the Commissions and their manifold flaws. Moreover, he is a sincere patriot who has volunteered many times for dangerous assignments in the course of his military service. His is a voice that should be heeded, and his nuanced views, if accepted and implemented, will redeem every freedom-loving American. Thank you, Andy, for yet another fine article.