On Monday and Tuesday evenings, the BBC’s Newsnight ran an extraordinary two-part feature on Guantánamo, bringing former guard Brandon Neely over from the United States to meet — and apologize to — former prisoners Shafiq Rasul and Ruhal Ahmed, two of “The Tipton Three,” from the West Midlands, who were freed in March 2004 and whose story was later featured in “The Road to Guantánamo,” a powerful film about their experiences.
Brandon Neely served at Guantánamo in the first six months of the prison’s existence, between January and June 2002. He was then deployed to Iraq, but when the Army attempted to recall him from his Inactive Ready Reserve (IRR) status to active duty in May 2007, he ignored every letter and email, until the Army gave up, granting him an honorable discharge in June 2008.
A vocal opponent of the war and president of the Houston chapter of Iraq Veterans Against the War, Brandon has explained that he saw “a lot of bad and horrible things and have done them too while over there,” but it was not until 2008 that he also began tentatively to speak out about Guantánamo.
In October 2008, he told Courage to Resist, “You know, when we first got there they put it into your head — I can remember them telling us, you know, these are the worst of the worst, these are the guys who plotted 9/11,” but added that after the first prisoners arrived, “actually talking to some of these detainees — and there were a lot of young ones too — and some guys, they seemed like common people.”
A month later, I received an email out of the blue from Brandon, in which he thanked me for my work and wrote, “It’s nice to see that someone is helping to give a voice to these people who mostly were wrongfully held.” He also explained, “When I was in Gitmo I was 21. I was young and didn’t know what was going on really. You’re told one thing and go with it, but over time I realized that it was wrong. So many of those people were innocent.”
I’ve been in touch with Brandon on and off ever since, and was pleased when he agreed to give a detailed interview to UC Davis’ Guantánamo Testimonials Project, which was published in February 2009.
In my email exchange with him, Brandon wrote that he had had discussions with the Australian prisoner David Hicks, but I didn’t know until this week that he had also spoken to the British prisoners — Shafiq, Ruhal and Asif Iqbal — and that, around the time he got in touch with me, he found Shafiq on Facebook and sent him a message, apologizing for his part in the ill-treatment of Shafiq and the other prisoners at Guantánamo, which eventually led to the meeting orchestrated by the BBC.
It was a genuinely touching meeting, and I was impressed that Brandon had found the courage to meet Shafiq and Ruhal, and to apologize to them in person (which, after all, is easier said than done), and pleased also that his criticism of Guantánamo — and the fact that Shafiq and Ruhal, who are playing pool when we meet them in the BBC’s film, and are clearly not “the worst of the worst” — put out such a clear message about the injustice of Guantánamo on the eighth anniversary of the prison’s opening.
As Brandon stated at one point, recalling discussions with Ruhal in Guantánamo, “It was no different from me sitting at the bar with a friend of mine talking about women or music. He would say, ‘You ever listen to Eminem or Dr. Dre?’ and he threw off a little rap and it was just funny. I thought how could it be somebody is here who’s doing the same stuff that I do when I’m back home?”
In the United States, in contrast to this important reflection on the human cost of the Bush administration’s largely indiscriminate post-9/11 dragnet, opposition to the closure of Guantánamo has been ramped up horribly in the last two weeks, after opportunist lawmakers and pundits stirred up fear and paranoia in the wake of the failed plane bomb on Christmas Day. With President Obama capitulating to unreasonable demands to prevent the release of any more cleared Yemeni prisoners, the supporters of Guantánamo appear to have derailed the closure of the prison for the foreseeable future.
The two parts of Newsnight’s feature are available on the BBC website here and here, but in the hope of making this meeting available to a global audience, the blogger Rick B announced on his site Ten Percent that he has made the second part (in which the men meet) available as a two-part video on YouTube. Both parts are posted below:
As Rick B explained in a message accompanying the videos, “Note to BBC Newsnight: I have a TV license. I think this story should be seen internationally, so I have taken the liberty of putting this online for a global audience. I hope you take a more enlightened view of copyright on this than the standard corporate line due to its overwhelming public interest value.”
POSTSCRIPT: Revealing that they do indeed have “an enlightened view” of publicity in the age of the Internet, I’ve been informed by the BBC that a TV documentary on the reunion (essentially, the two Newsnight films made into one) will be showing on BBC World from next Wednesday (Jan. 20), so that international viewers can see it, and an extended version will be shown in the UK on the News Channel on Saturday Jan. 23 at 0530, 1430, and 2130 and Sunday Jan. 24 at 0330, 1030 and 1430.
Also, Radio 5 Live ran an extended audio version of the programme on Thursday Jan 14, and the World Service will broadcast it in its Assignment slot from Wednesday Jan. 20, when listeners will be able to download a podcast from the Assignment website. Please spread the word!
Andy Worthington is the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison (published by Pluto Press, distributed by Macmillan in the US, and available from Amazon — click on the following for the US and the UK). To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to my RSS feed (and I can also be found on Facebook and Twitter). Also see my definitive Guantánamo prisoner list, updated in January 2010, details about the new documentary film, “Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo” (co-directed by Polly Nash and Andy Worthington, and launched in October 2009), and, if you appreciate my work, feel free to make a donation.
[...] Andy Worthington Featured Writer Dandelion Salad http://www.andyworthington.co.uk 14 January [...]
People they suffered in deffirent ways, but the most horrible crime human being can do is to separate famillies, to be separated from the last days of pregnant spouse, and not to see your baby for more than four or five years! then they release you in to the mental torture of so called control orders! more pressure to see your spouse mental health degrading,taking away your kids freedom, destroying your family unit in front of your eyes! for what?!! I REALLY DON’T KNOW!!! this is the British government standing shoulder to shoulder with USA to fight for thier values God knows what does that means!!!who picks up the peices, are the women left behind to care for a damage mental state of the children.
Thanks for the message, A A. It’s good to hear from you, and I hope other readers appreciate what is clearly a voice of experience from the front line of this so-called “War on Terror.”
[...] a member of the ISOC – what if he was in the wrong place at the wrong time (God forbid) like these two ex-prisoners? I feel afraid for him every time he goes out, not because I think he may be radicalised – he [...]
[...] I have not re-lived what I did or saw in Guantánamo.” Hicks reached out to Neely last year after he saw him on a BBC special. Neely had flown to London to meet a couple of former British detainees he used to guard and to [...]
Investigative journalist, author, filmmaker, photographer and Guantanamo expert
Email Andy Worthington
Please support Andy Worthington, independent journalist: